Menu of Lost Pizza Co. Auburn in Auburn, Alabama, USA

Menu Overview

Lost Pizza Co. Auburn, located on E Samford Ave, offers a hearty slice of Southern-inspired pizza fare with a distinct Auburn vibe. Walking into this pizza joint feels like stepping into a family-friendly hub, where the aroma of fresh-baked crust meets the warmth of welcoming service. The menu strikes a fine balance between comforting classics and bold regional flavors, making it a versatile choice for locals and visitors alike.

The starters set the tone for the meal. The Mississippi Delta Hot Tamales stand out, hand-rolled with a unique spice blend that packs a subtle kick, served alongside Saltine Crackers and hot sauce. It’s a starter that echoes the Delta’s culinary heritage with a satisfying crunch and heat. Meanwhile, the Olive Bread Sticks deliver a savory punch with a garlic butter crust topped generously with olive salad and a house cheese blend. The accompanying Marinara Sauce adds the perfect tangy touch, elevating this starter beyond the standard garlic bread options.

Moving to the pizza lineup, the Build-Your-Own option rewards creativity, allowing customization of size, crust, sauces, and toppings, all resting on a solid foundation of their signature cheese blend. This flexibility caters to those who appreciate personal flair on their pie. Customer favorites frequently mention the thin crust variety, praised for its crispy texture and balanced cheesiness, notably more satisfying than the regular crust, which received mixed reviews.

Signature pies such as the Happy Hippy incorporate fresh, chunky artichokes that add an earthy depth, reminiscent of Mediterranean flavors that pair well with the robust cheeses. The Hot Chick Pizza offers a buffalo chicken variation but divides opinions; some find it hits the mark with flavor and spice, while others feel it could use more refinement. A safer bet seems to be the classic pepperoni and roasted garlic combination, which delivers well-rounded, savory notes with plenty of bite.

Beyond pizza, the skillet-fried delights like the Fried Ravioli (meat-filled version) and Wings earn praise for their bold flavors and flavorful crispness, especially the bone-in wings that many patrons rave about. These sides perfectly complement the main course, adding contrasting textures and tastes.

While the pizza sauce leans towards a simpler, Midwest-style profile, lacking intense herbaceous or rich tomato notes, it meshes well with the crust and cheese combo, keeping the pies approachable and crowd-pleasing. Pricing is notably reasonable, facilitating an inviting space for families and groups without breaking the bank.

Service at Lost Pizza Co. Auburn shines through as a key highlight. Friendly staff, prompt delivery of hot dishes, and an overall smooth dining experience elevate the casual atmosphere. It’s clear the team values customer engagement, creating a relaxed environment where diners feel at home.

In summary, Lost Pizza Co. Auburn is a strong addition to Auburn’s casual dining scene. It pairs down-home Southern charm with a well-curated menu featuring standout starters, a versatile build-your-own pizza system, and a solid lineup of sides and signature pies. Though the pizza sauce and some crust options may not please every palate, the overall warmth of the space, quality of ingredients, and thoughtful menu variety make it a reliable spot for family meals, group hangouts, or a laid-back night out. Expect good food, great service, and that inviting Southern hospitality that keeps guests coming back.