Lost Pizza Co. Auburn, located on E Samford Ave, is a refreshing addition to Auburn’s vibrant food scene. This pizza joint strikes a balance between casual comfort and family-friendly warmth. Whether you’re after a quick bite or a relaxed meal with friends and family, Lost Pizza Co. provides an inviting space with plenty of seating and a lively yet laid-back atmosphere.
The heart of their menu lies in their build-your-own pizza options, allowing diners to customize crust thickness, sauces, and toppings. The thin crust stands out for its crispiness and light chew, delivering a satisfying base that complements their ample cheese blend and fresh, well-chosen toppings. Signature pizzas like the “Happy Hippy” impressed with chunky artichokes and balanced flavors, while the “Islander” with jalapeños offers a zesty kick. While some customers found the traditional crust and buffalo chicken pizza less compelling, the thin crust remains a crowd favorite.
Beyond pizza, Lost Pizza Co. offers sandwiches toasted on garlic-buttered hoagies, such as the Mr. G—layered with cherrywood ham, oven-roasted turkey, and provolone enriched by a house Italian dressing. Appetizers like fried ravioli and wings are flavorful crowd-pleasers, especially the bone-in wings noted for their robust seasoning and perfect cooking.
The service at Lost Pizza Co. Auburn is consistently praised for being friendly and attentive, contributing greatly to the overall dining experience. Staff engagement, like Bernard’s approachable demeanor, adds a personal touch that makes guests feel at home. The restaurant’s vibe is approachable and unpretentious, well-suited for families, groups, and casual get-togethers without the pressure of formal dining.
For those seeking affordable and straightforward American-style pizza with options for customization, Lost Pizza Co. offers a worthy stop. While some of the sauces and sides lean towards simplicity, the combination of quick service, generous portions, and a welcoming environment makes it a solid choice for locals and visitors alike.
In summary, Lost Pizza Co. Auburn shines as a dependable, relaxed locale for pizza lovers and families. Its strength lies in its thin crust pizzas, flexible menu, and warm hospitality, all wrapped in a cozy Auburn neighborhood setting.
